February 23, 2024
When it comes to choosing between metal roofing services or asphalt roof installation, there are quite a few factors to consider. Both have their advantages, but one may better suit your needs than another, so the commercial and residential roofing professionals from Advanced Roofing Solutions have compiled this insightful guide for you about the key differences between metal and asphalt roofing.
What’s the Cost Differential?
One of the largest differences between metal and asphalt roofing is the cost of the materials and labor. There are numerous types of metal roofing and asphalt shingles on the market today to choose from. When it comes to installing traditional asphalt shingles, the cost is often calculated by the square footage of shingles that need to be installed on your roof and can range anywhere from $4.25–$4.95 per square foot; architectural asphalt shingles range from $4.50–$8.25 per square foot.
The variety of metal roofing materials out there are often more expensive, but there are quite a few to choose from offering various price points such as:
- Standing-Seam Metal Panels: $10–$17.05 per square foot
- Steel Shingles: $8–$12.65 per square foot
- Corrugated Metal Panels: $5.50–$11.50 per square foot
- Aluminum Shingles: $8.50–$13.75 per square foot
- Copper Shingles: $21–$39.70 per square foot
Other Price-Related Factors to Consider
There are some other aspects to consider when choosing between asphalt and metal roofing than simply the square footage costs of materials and labor including:
- Lifespan: Taking into account the durability and lifespan of the particular roof you choose is key, as you’ll be able to determine how long it will take to see a return on your investment (ROI). It’s no secret metal roofing can be more costly upfront, but the durability of metal roofing materials offers a great ROI. Additionally, they often come with extensive warranties that last anywhere from 30-50 years. Asphalt shingles are much cheaper upfront and also include warranties ranging anywhere from 15-30 years. However, they can be more vulnerable to extreme weather and climates, resulting in a shorter lifespan.
- Roofing Maintenance: Another thing to consider is the price of properly maintaining your new metal or asphalt roof. Since metal roofs are much less susceptible to damage from moisture and extreme weather, they also require less maintenance and repairs. Either way, depending on which material you choose, having your roof professionally inspected annually is always recommended.
- Installation: One key thing that will factor into the price differential is that asphalt shingle roofs are much easier and quicker to install than metal roofs. Often it takes as little as two days to install asphalt shingles and they can be installed over your old roof in some cases, meaning roofers don’t need to tear away your old roof, significantly lowering labor costs. Metal roofing however is much heavier and can’t be installed atop an existing roof. Metal roof installation also requires specialized experts, and this factor may add to the overall cost.
- Sustainability: If you want to choose a sustainable and eco-friendly roofing option, then metal roofing is the way to go. This is because metal can be easily refurbished or recycled for other purposes. They’re also designed to reflect sunlight. Asphalt shingles on the other hand are petroleum-based and can’t be recycled, adding to waste, and increasing the dependency on fossil fuels.
Metal & Asphalt Roofing PROs & CONs
PROs of Metal Roofing:
- Lasts upwards of 70 years with proper maintenance
- More energy-efficient and eco-friendly
- Requires less maintenance throughout the years
CONs of Metal Roofing:
- Installation is more labor-intensive
- The cost upfront is greater than asphalt roofing installation costs
PROs of Asphalt Roofing:
- It comes in a much wider variety of colors, and styles
- The upfront installation costs are much less than metal roofs
- Installation is quicker and easier, resulting in lower labor costs
CONs of Asphalt Roofing:
- Provides less insulation during hotter and colder months
- Needs maintenance much more frequently than metal roofs
What to Consider When Choosing a Roofing Type
There are some key considerations when it comes to choosing your roofing type in addition to cost, such as:
- Roof Slope: The slope of your home’s roof can be a major factor when installing a new roof since it affects wind resistance and water runoff. Roofs with minimal sloping will often require more durable materials to avoid damage from standing water in certain areas.
- Climate: The climate where you live is key when it comes to new roof installation. Those living in areas that frequently experience extreme weather, high humidity, or wildfires should consider installing a roof type that’s as durable and resistant to such factors as possible.
- Budget: After taking all of the cost differentials mentioned above into consideration, it’s important to ensure that the overall costs fit within your budget range. A comprehensive budget needs to include material, labor, maintenance, and repair costs.
Contact us today for metal roofing services in Fayetteville and more
If you’re in need of a new roof, Advanced Roofing Solutions can help you find the perfect one for your price range. In addition to metal and asphalt roofing installation, we also specialize in commercial roof replacement and inspections, and flat roof services in Fayetteville, NC.
As a GAF-certified roofer, you can rest assured when you place your trust in us for any roof replacement or repairs, you’ll receive the very best materials and service. Over the years, Advanced Roofing Solutions has developed a strong reputation for providing outstanding customer service and getting the job done right every time.
Get a FREE estimate by contacting us online today or calling 1 (910) 988-8245.